What is the difference between optical and radar satellites?

Optical satellites photograph sunlight reflected from the ground; radar satellites send out their own microwave pulses, so they can see at night and through clouds.

Earth-observation satellites come in two big families. NASA's Earthdata explains the difference in one line each. Passive instruments detect energy that comes naturally from the scene, such as reflected sunlight. Active instruments send out their own energy and measure what comes back.

Optical: passive Radar: active Camera Radar (SAR) Sunlight Blocked Cloud Pulse Echo Cloud Needs daylight, clear sky Works through cloud, day or night
An optical satellite is passive: it records sunlight reflected from the ground, so it needs daylight and cannot see through cloud. A radar satellite is active: it sends its own microwave pulse, which passes through cloud, and records the echo, day or night.

Optical: a camera in the sky

An optical satellite works like a very powerful camera. India's Cartosat-3 is an example. ISRO calls it a third-generation agile satellite with high-resolution imaging capability. PSLV-C47 placed it in a 509 km orbit inclined at 97.5° on 27 November 2019.

Optical images are easy for people to read: they look like photographs. But they need daylight, and they cannot see through cloud. During India's monsoon, that is a serious problem.

Radar: bring your own light

A radar satellite sends microwave pulses and records the echoes. Earthdata says this lets it make high-resolution images night or day, regardless of weather. Microwaves pass through clouds and rain that would block an optical camera.

India's EOS-04 is a radar imaging satellite designed to give high-quality images under all weather conditions. PSLV-C52 placed it in a 529 km sun-synchronous orbit on 14 February 2022. ISRO lists its uses as agriculture, forestry and plantations, soil moisture and hydrology, and flood mapping.

Radar images look different from photos. Their brightness depends on the roughness and structure of the surface rather than its colour, so they take training to read.

Which is better?

Neither. Optical gives colour and fine detail on clear days. Radar is reliable in every weather. ISRO's National Remote Sensing Centre says microwave data are of the highest use during floods, exactly when clouds hide the ground from optical satellites. The two are most powerful when used together.

See it live

Search for Cartosat-3 and EOS-04: both fly low sun-synchronous orbits around 500 km, but one carries a camera and the other a radar. Find Cartosat-3 and EOS-04

Key facts

  • Cartosat-3 (optical): 509 km orbit, 97.5° inclination, launched 27 November 2019 on PSLV-C47.
  • EOS-04 (radar): 529 km sun-synchronous orbit, launched 14 February 2022 on PSLV-C52.
  • EOS-04: about 1,710 kg, 2,280 W, 10-year mission life.
  • Radar is active: it supplies its own microwave energy.
  • NRSC: microwave data are most useful during floods, when clouds block optical sensors.

Go deeper

The two families use wavelengths that differ by a factor of about a hundred thousand.

Visible light: around 0.5 μm = 5 × 10⁻⁷ m. Radar bands (Earthdata): X-band about 2.4–3.8 cm, C-band about 3.8–7.5 cm, S-band 7.5–15 cm, L-band 15–30 cm.

Take L-band at 24 cm (NISAR's L-band wavelength): 0.24 / 5 × 10⁻⁷ = 480,000 times longer than visible light. Cloud droplets are tiny compared with a radar wavelength, so they barely scatter the radar pulse; to visible light they are large, so a cloud is opaque.

Wavelength also controls what radar sees inside a forest. Earthdata notes that short X-band waves mostly bounce off leaves at the top of the canopy, while longer L-band and P-band waves reach branches and trunks.

The cost of being active is power. A radar's echo must travel to the ground and back, and the received power falls as 1/R⁴ (1/R² on the way down, 1/R² on the way back). Doubling the distance cuts the echo to 1/16. Power matters for radar satellites: EOS-04's solar arrays generate about 2,280 W.

A camera's echo problem does not exist: sunlight does the illuminating, and the satellite only receives. But it also cannot work without the Sun, which is why optical Earth-observation satellites use sun-synchronous orbits that pass over at the same convenient local time each day.

Check yourself

Classify optical cameras and radar as active or passive sensors.

Optical cameras are passive (they use reflected sunlight); radar is active (it sends out its own microwave pulses).

Why is radar preferred for mapping floods during the monsoon?

Microwaves pass through clouds and rain and work at night, so radar can image flooded areas that clouds hide from optical cameras.

Which penetrates deeper into a forest canopy, X-band or L-band radar?

L-band, because its longer wavelength passes the leaves and reaches branches and trunks.

Sources

  1. What is Remote Sensing? — NASA Earthdata
  2. What is Synthetic Aperture Radar? — NASA Earthdata
  3. PSLV-C47 / Cartosat-3 Mission — ISRO
  4. EOS-04 — ISRO
  5. PSLV-C52/EOS-04 Mission — ISRO
  6. Successful launch of PSLV-C52 with EOS-04 — ISRO
  7. Disaster Management Support — applications — NRSC
  8. NISAR Mission Overview — Quick Facts — NASA Science